Title:Lower bounds on collective additive spanners

Abstract:In this paper we present various lower bound results on collective tree spanners and on spanners of bounded treewidth. A graph $G$ is said to admit a system of $\mu$ collective additive tree $c$-spanners if there is a system $\cal{T}$$(G)$ of at most $\mu$ spanning trees of $G$ such that for any two vertices $u,v$ of $G$ a tree $T\in \cal{T}$$(G)$ exists such that the distance in $T$ between $u$ and $v$ is at most $c$ plus their distance in $G$. A graph $G$ is said to admit an additive $k$-treewidth $c$-spanner if there is a spanning subgraph $H$ of $G$ with treewidth $k$ such that for any pair of vertices $u$ and $v$ their distance in $H$ is at most $c$ plus their distance in $G$. Among other results, we show that:
$\bullet$ Any system of collective additive tree $1$ -- spanners must have $\Omega(\sqrt[3]{\log n})$ spanning trees for some unit interval graphs;
$\bullet$ No system of a constant number of collective additive tree $2$-spanners can exist for strongly chordal graphs;
$\bullet$ No system of a constant number of collective additive tree $3$-spanners can exist for chordal graphs;
$\bullet$ No system of a constant number of collective additive tree $c$-spanners can exist for weakly chordal graphs as well as for outerplanar graphs for any constant $c\geq 0$;
$\bullet$ For any constants $k \ge 2$ and $c \ge 1$ there are graphs of treewidth $k$ such that no spanning subgraph of treewidth $k-1$ can be an additive $c$-spanner of such a graph.
All these lower bound results apply also to general graphs. Furthermore, they %results complement known upper bound results with tight lower bound results.