Title:Majorana polarization in disordered heterostructures

Abstract:Recent studies propose Majorana polarization (MP) as a tool for identifying topological Majorana bound states (MBS). We analyze MP in two systems: a one-dimensional (1d) semiconducting nanowire and a finite-size graphene strip, both with Rashba spin-orbit coupling, proximity-induced superconductivity, and disorder. While MP reflects topological features, it does not always distinguish true MBS from partially separated Andreev bound states (psABS) or quasi-Majorana modes. True MBS are expected to satisfy $\mathcal{P}^\mathrm{left} \cdot \mathcal{P}^\mathrm{right} \sim -1$, but two additional criteria - a topological bandgap and edge-localized wavefunctions - are also necessary for their identification and use in topological quantum computation (TQC). We highlight cases where the polarization product condition holds without meeting these extra requirements. In finite graphene strips, disorder blurs the complex topological phase diagram, with isolated regions showing $\mathcal{P}^\mathrm{right}\approx-\mathcal{P}^\mathrm{left}$ and $|\mathcal{P}^\mathrm{left}|\gtrsim \frac{1}{2}$. Even here, MP alone cannot reliably distinguish true MBS from quasi-Majorana or trivial states. Robust MBS identification for TQC demands combining MP with energy spectra and wavefunction localization, especially in disordered systems.