Title:Comments to Marvel Fusions Mixed Fuels Reactor Concept

Abstract:Nanostructured solid boron-hydrogen compounds have been suggested as target and fuel for laser fusion, offering improved laser-plasma coupling, avoiding cryogenic fuel handling and fuel pre-compression and ultimately allowing a transit from DT- to aneutronic pB- fusion power production. We describe the scaling of the different energy loss channels ({\alpha}-particle escape, bremsstrahlung, hydrodynamic expansion work, electron heat conduction) with mixed fuel composition using partial inverse gains (Q's) which allow a simple superposition of losses. This highlights in particular the negative synergy between these loss-channels for such mixed fuels: the dominance of bremsstrahlung over fusion power at low temperatures forces a shift of operation to higher ones, where the plasma gets more transparent to {\alpha}-particles, and hydrodynamic and heat conduction losses increase strongly. The use of mixed fuels therefore does not eliminate the need for strong precompression of the fuel: in fact, it renders achieving burning plasma conditions much more difficult, if not impossible. A recent suggestion to use tamping of the fuel by cladding with a heavy metal would only reduce hydrodynamic expansion losses significantly if the cladding could cover most of the fuel surface, in competition with access to laser radiation. But even if tamping were perfect, this would not reduce the remaining three loss channels - in fact it would have a negative effect on burn propagation, as the escaping energy would not heat surrounding fuel, but only the cladding material.