Title:Halo Exclusion Criteria Impacts Halo Statistics

Abstract:Every halo finding algorithm must make a critical yet relatively arbitrary choice: it must decide which structures are parent halos, and which structures are sub-halos of larger halos. We refer to this choice as ${\it percolation}$. We demonstrate that the choice of percolation impacts the statistical properties of the resulting halo catalog. Specifically, we modify the halo-finding algorithm ${\tt ROCKSTAR}$ to construct four different halo catalogs from the same simulation data, each with identical mass definitions, but different choice of percolation. The resulting halos exhibit significant differences in both halo abundance and clustering properties. Differences in the halo mass function reach $10\%$ for halos of mass $10^{13}\ h^{-1}\ {\rm M_{\odot}}$, larger than the few percent precision necessary for current cluster abundance experiments such as the Dark Energy Survey. Comparable differences are observed in the large-scale clustering bias, while differences in the halo--matter correlation function reach $40\%$ on translinear scales. These effects can bias weak-lensing estimates of cluster masses at a level comparable to the statistical precision of current state-of-the-art experiments.