Title:The scalar glueball and the loss of conformality

Abstract:We show that the anomalous dimension $\gamma_G$ of the scalar glueball operator tells us which mechanism leads to the loss of conformality at the lower edge of the conformal window in a non-Abelian gauge theory. In particular, it tells us whether the merging of a UV and an IR fixed point - the simplest mechanism associated to a conformal (Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless) phase transition and preconformal scaling - does or does not occur. We illustrate this with examples. In SQCD it does not occur. Indeed, we show that an exact relation between $\gamma_G$ and the mass anomalous dimension $\gamma_m$ - one way in which confinement and chiral symmetry breaking are intertwined - exists and that this relation, global R symmetry and the $a$-theorem imply a strictly monotone and non vanishing $\gamma_G$ as opposed to merging, where a non monotone $\gamma_G$ vanishing at the lower edge is implied.
Perhaps not surprisingly, we show that the same exact relation between $\gamma_G$ and $\gamma_m$ holds for large N QCD in the Veneziano limit, naturally leading to the same incompatibility and suggesting that this may extend to QCD at finite N. We also investigate the possibility that an effective four-fermion coupling is needed in the description of strongly coupled QCD inside the conformal window, possibly leading to a multiple coupling realisation of merging. However, we observe that this effective description cannot produce a nontrivial UV fixed point, hence merging, and at the same time recover the perturbative IR fixed point of the QCD conformal window.