Title:Statistical issues in Serial Killer Nurse cases

Abstract:We discuss cases of serial killer nurses, focussing on the Dutch case of the nurse Lucia de Berk, arrested under suspicion of murder in 2001, convicted to life imprisonment, but declared innocent in 2010; and the case of the English nurse Ben Geen, arrested in 2004, also given a life sentence. At the trial of Ben Geen, a statistical expert was refused permission to present evidence on statistical biases concerning the way suspicious cases were identified by a hospital team of investigators. The judge ruled that the expert's written evidence was merely common sense. An application to the CCRC to review the case was turned down, since the application only presented statistical evidence but did not re-address the medical evidence presented at the original trials. This rejection has been successfully challenged in court, however the CCRC has again turned down the application. The paper includes some new statistical findings on the Ben Geen case as well as giving advice to statisticians involved in future cases. The experiences recounted here have contributed to the writing of the manual Green et al. (2022), Healthcare Serial Killer or Coincidence? Statistical Issues in Investigation of Suspected Medical Misconduct, commissioned by the Royal Statistical Society, Statistics and the Law section.