Title:What is the joint system-bath state?

Abstract:The initial state of a system-bath composite is needed as the input for prediction from any quantum evolution equation to describe, for example, the noise on the system from joint evolution of the system-bath interaction dynamics. The conventional wisdom is to simply write down an uncorrelated state as if the system and bath were prepared in the absence of each other; or one uses a symbolic system-bath state, allowing for possible arbitrary correlations--quantum or classical--between the system and the bath, but the latter approach lacks predictive power unless one can say something about that symbolic state. Here, we show how one uses ideas from quantum tomography or state estimation to deduce an initial system-bath state consistent with the available information. In typical experimentally relevant situations, such a state turns out to be uncorrelated or almost uncorrelated between the system and the bath. This has implications on the subject of subsequent non-Markovian or non-completely-positive dynamics of the system, where the non-complete-positivity stems from initial nontrivial correlations between the system and the bath. Deviation from predictions based on such an almost uncorrelated state can be indicative of accidental control of hidden degrees of freedom in the bath.