Economics
- [1] arXiv:2405.13169 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Evaluating Offshore Electricity Market Design Considering Endogenous Infrastructure Investments: Zonal or Nodal?Subjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
Policy makers are formulating offshore energy infrastructure plans, including wind turbines, electrolyzers, and HVDC transmission lines. An effective market design is crucial to guide cost-efficient investments and dispatch decisions. This paper jointly studies the impact of offshore market design choices on the investment in offshore electrolyzers and HVDC transmission capacity. We present a bilevel model that incorporates investments in offshore energy infrastructure, day-ahead market dispatch, and potential redispatch actions near real-time to ensure transmission constraints are respected. Our findings demonstrate that full nodal pricing, i.e., nodal pricing both onshore and offshore, outperforms the onshore zonal combined with offshore nodal pricing or offshore zonal layouts. While combining onshore zonal with offshore nodal pricing can be considered as a second-best option, it generally diminishes the profitability of offshore wind farms. However, if investment costs of offshore electrolyzers are relatively low, they can serve as catalysts to increase the revenues of the offshore wind farms. This study contributes to the understanding of market designs for highly interconnected offshore power systems, offering insights into the impact of congestion pricing methodologies on investment decisions. Besides, it is useful towards understanding the interaction of offshore loads like electrolyzers with financial support mechanisms for offshore wind farms.
- [2] arXiv:2405.13186 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Doing the right thing (or not) in a lemons-like situation: on the role of social preferences and Kantian moral concernsSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
We conduct a laboratory experiment using framing to assess the willingness to ``sell a lemon'', i.e., to undertake an action that benefits self but hurts the other (the ``buyer''). We seek to disentangle the role of other-regarding preferences and (Kantian) moral concerns, and to test if it matters whether the decision is described in neutral terms or as a market situation. When evaluating an action, morally motivated individuals consider what their own payoff would be if -- hypothetically -- the roles were reversed and the other subject chose the same action (universalization). We vary the salience of role uncertainty, thus varying the ease for participants to envisage the role-reversal scenario.
- [3] arXiv:2405.13241 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Selecting Experimental Sites for External ValidityMichael Gechter, Keisuke Hirano, Jean Lee, Mahreen Mahmud, Orville Mondal, Jonathan Morduch, Saravana Ravindran, Abu S. ShonchoySubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
Policy decisions often depend on evidence generated elsewhere. We take a Bayesian decision-theoretic approach to choosing where to experiment to optimize external validity. We frame external validity through a policy lens, developing a prior specification for the joint distribution of site-level treatment effects using a microeconometric structural model and allowing for other sources of heterogeneity. With data from South Asia, we show that, relative to basing policies on experiments in optimal sites, large efficiency losses result from instead using evidence from randomly-selected sites or, conversely, from sites with the largest expected treatment effects.
- [4] arXiv:2405.13251 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Valores extremos de inflaci\'on en Costa RicaComments: in Spanish language. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2405.12240Subjects: General Economics (econ.GN); Applications (stat.AP)
Maintaining low, non-negative and stable inflation levels is a necessary condition for the stability of the economy as a whole, because the monetary authorities of most industrialized countries, including the Central Bank of Costa Rica since 2005, they have oriented their monetary policy precisely to that task. Still Thus, both in Costa Rica and internationally, most of the statistical modeling of inflation has been limited to modeling their expectancy conditional on different covariates using linear models. This implies a lack of knowledge of the dynamics of the extreme values of the inflation rate and how these are related with other macroeconomic variables. In Costa Rica this is of particular importance since in several periods Negative quarter-on-quarter inflation rates have recently been experienced, which can be problematic if this becomes a recurring phenomenon. Therefore, in this work we propose to answer what is the relationship between the gap of GDP, inflation expectations, imported inflation rate, and the extreme values of the inflation rate in Costa Rica. That is, the main objective is to determine the relationship between the extreme values of the the inflation rate, GDP gap, inflation expectations and imported inflation.
- [5] arXiv:2405.13296 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: The Debt-Inflation Channel of the German (Hyper-)InflationSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
This paper studies how a large increase in the price level is transmitted to the real economy through firm balance sheets. Using newly digitized macro- and micro-level data from the German inflation of 1919-1923, we show that inflation led to a large reduction in real debt burdens and bankruptcies. Firms with higher nominal liabilities at the onset of inflation experienced a larger decline in interest expenses, a relative increase in their equity values, and higher employment during the inflation. The results are consistent with real effects of a debt-inflation channel that operates even when prices and wages are flexible.
- [6] arXiv:2405.13327 [pdf, ps, other]
-
Title: Monitoring the carbon emissions transition of global building end-use activityComments: 7 pages, 6 figuresSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
The building sector is the largest emitter globally and as such is at the forefront of the net-zero emissions pathway. This study is the first to present a bottom-up assessment framework integrated with the decomposing structural decomposition method to evaluate the emission patterns and decarbonization process of global residential building operations and commercial building operation simultaneously over the last two decades. The results reveal that (1) the average carbon intensity of global commercial building operations has maintained an annual decline of 1.94% since 2000, and emission factors and industrial structures were generally the key to decarbonizing commercial building operations; (2) the operational carbon intensity of global residential buildings has maintained an annual decline of 1.2% over the past two decades, and energy intensity and average household size have been key to this decarbonization; and (3) the total decarbonization of commercial building operations and residential buildings worldwide was 230.28 and 338.1 mega-tons of carbon dioxide per yr, respectively, with a decarbonization efficiency of 10.05% and 9.4%. Overall, this study assesses the global historical progress in decarbonizing global building operations and closes the relevant gap, and it helps plan the stepwise carbon neutral pathway of future global buildings by the mid-century.
- [7] arXiv:2405.13341 [pdf, ps, other]
-
Title: Wealth inequality and utility: Effect evaluation of redistribution and consumption morals using macro-econophysical coupled approachComments: 27 pages, 6 figuresSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN); Multiagent Systems (cs.MA); Physics and Society (physics.soc-ph)
Reducing wealth inequality and increasing utility are critical issues. This study reveals the effects of redistribution and consumption morals on wealth inequality and utility. To this end, we present a novel approach that couples the dynamic model of capital, consumption, and utility in macroeconomics with the interaction model of joint business and redistribution in econophysics. With this approach, we calculate the capital (wealth), the utility based on consumption, and the Gini index of these inequality using redistribution and consumption thresholds as moral parameters. The results show that: under-redistribution and waste exacerbate inequality; conversely, over-redistribution and stinginess reduce utility; and a balanced moderate moral leads to achieve both reduced inequality and increased utility. These findings provide renewed economic and numerical support for the moral importance known from philosophy, anthropology, and religion. The revival of redistribution and consumption morals should promote the transformation to a human mutual-aid economy, as indicated by philosopher and anthropologist, instead of the capitalist economy that has produced the current inequality. The practical challenge is to implement bottom-up social business, on a foothold of worker coops and platform cooperatives as a community against the state and the market, with moral consensus and its operation.
- [8] arXiv:2405.13422 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Learning Trade Opportunities through Production NetworkComments: 34 pages, 8 tablesSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
Using data on the Spanish firm-level production network we show that firms learn about international trade opportunities and related business know-how from their production network peers. Our identification strategy leverages the panel structure of the data, import origin variation, and network structure. We find evidence of both upstream and downstream network effects, even after accounting for sectoral and geographical spillovers. Larger firms are better at absorbing valuable information but worse at disseminating it. Connections with geographically distant firms provide more useful information to start importing.
- [9] arXiv:2405.13709 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Comparisons of Sequential Experiments for Additively Separable ProblemsSubjects: Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
For three natural classes of dynamic decision problems; 1. additively separable problems, 2. discounted problems, and 3. discounted problems for a fixed discount factor; we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for one sequential experiment to dominate another in the sense that the dominant experiment is preferred to the other for any decision problem in the specified class. We use these results to study the timing of information arrival in additively separable problems.
- [10] arXiv:2405.13945 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Exogenous Consideration and Extended Random UtilityComments: 44 pagesSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM)
In a consideration set model, an individual maximizes utility among the considered alternatives. I relate a consideration set additive random utility model to classic discrete choice and the extended additive random utility model, in which utility can be $-\infty$ for infeasible alternatives. When observable utility shifters are bounded, all three models are observationally equivalent. Moreover, they have the same counterfactual bounds and welfare formulas for changes in utility shifters like price. For attention interventions, welfare cannot change in the full consideration model but is completely unbounded in the limited consideration model. The identified set for consideration set probabilities has a minimal width for any bounded support of shifters, but with unbounded support it is a point: identification "towards" infinity does not resemble identification "at" infinity.
- [11] arXiv:2405.14104 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: On the Identifying Power of Monotonicity for Average Treatment EffectsSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM); Methodology (stat.ME)
In the context of a binary outcome, treatment, and instrument, Balke and Pearl (1993, 1997) establish that adding monotonicity to the instrument exogeneity assumption does not decrease the identified sets for average potential outcomes and average treatment effect parameters when those assumptions are consistent with the distribution of the observable data. We show that the same results hold in the broader context of multi-valued outcome, treatment, and instrument. An important example of such a setting is a multi-arm randomized controlled trial with noncompliance.
- [12] arXiv:2405.14611 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Is the EJRA proportionate and therefore justified? A critical review of the EJRA policy at CambridgeOliver Linton, Raghavendra Rau, Patrick Baert, Peter Bossaerts, Jon Crowcroft, Gill Evans, Paul Ewart, Robert Foley, Nick Gay, Paul Kattuman, Fermin Moscoso del Prado Martin, Stefan Scholtes, Hamid Sabourian, Richard J. SmithSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
This paper critically evaluates the HESA (Higher Education Statistics Agency) Data Report for the Employer Justified Retirement Age (EJRA) Review Group at the University of Cambridge (Cambridge 2024), identifying significant methodological flaws and misinterpretations. Our analysis reveals issues such as application of data filters only to the Cambridge sample, inconsistent variable treatment, and erroneous statistical conclusions. The Report suggests EJRA increased job creation rates at Cambridge, but we show Cambridge consistently had lower job creation rates for Established Academic Careers compared to other Russell Group universities, both before and after EJRA implementation in 2011. This suggests that EJRA is not a significant factor driving job creation rates. Since other universities without an EJRA exhibit higher job creation rates, this suggests job creation can be sustained without such a policy. We conclude that the EJRA did not achieve its intended goal of increasing opportunities for young academics and may have exacerbated existing disparities compared to other leading universities. We recommend EJRA be abolished at Cambridge since it does not meet its justified aims and could be viewed as unlawful age discrimination.
- [13] arXiv:2405.14617 [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Towards an Optimal Staking Design: Balancing Security, User Growth, and Token AppreciationJournal-ref: Proceedings of the ChainScience 2024 ConferenceSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
This paper examines the economic and security implications of Proof-of-Stake (POS) designs, providing a survey of POS design choices and their underlying economic principles in prominent POS-blockchains. The paper argues that POS-blockchains are essentially platforms that connect three groups of agents: users, validators, and investors. To meet the needs of these groups, blockchains must balance trade-offs between security, user adoption, and investment into the protocol. We focus on the security aspect and identify two different strategies: increasing the quality of validators (static security) vs. increasing the quantity of stakes (dynamic security). We argue that quality comes at the cost of quantity, identifying a trade-off between the two strategies when designing POS systems. We test our qualitative findings using panel analysis on collected data. The analysis indicates that enhancing the quality of the validator set through security measures like slashing and minimum staking amounts may decrease dynamic security. Further, the analysis reveals a strategic divergence among blockchains, highlighting the absence of a single, universally optimal staking design solution. The optimal design hinges upon a platform's specific objectives and its developmental stage. This research compels blockchain developers to meticulously assess the trade-offs outlined in this paper when developing their staking designs.
New submissions for Friday, 24 May 2024 (showing 13 of 13 entries )
- [14] arXiv:2405.13224 (cross-list from physics.soc-ph) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Integrating behavioral experimental findings into dynamical models to inform social change interventionsComments: Main text pp. 1-13; Supplementary Material pp. 14-36Subjects: Physics and Society (physics.soc-ph); Social and Information Networks (cs.SI); Econometrics (econ.EM)
Addressing global challenges -- from public health to climate change -- often involves stimulating the large-scale adoption of new products or behaviors. Research traditions that focus on individual decision making suggest that achieving this objective requires better identifying the drivers of individual adoption choices. On the other hand, computational approaches rooted in complexity science focus on maximizing the propagation of a given product or behavior throughout social networks of interconnected adopters. The integration of these two perspectives -- although advocated by several research communities -- has remained elusive so far. Here we show how achieving this integration could inform seeding policies to facilitate the large-scale adoption of a given behavior or product. Drawing on complex contagion and discrete choice theories, we propose a method to estimate individual-level thresholds to adoption, and validate its predictive power in two choice experiments. By integrating the estimated thresholds into computational simulations, we show that state-of-the-art seeding methods for social influence maximization might be suboptimal if they neglect individual-level behavioral drivers, which can be corrected through the proposed experimental method.
- [15] arXiv:2405.13753 (cross-list from cs.LG) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: A Dynamic Model of Performative Human-ML Collaboration: Theory and Empirical EvidenceComments: 9 Pages and appendixSubjects: Machine Learning (cs.LG); Artificial Intelligence (cs.AI); Human-Computer Interaction (cs.HC); General Economics (econ.GN)
Machine learning (ML) models are increasingly used in various applications, from recommendation systems in e-commerce to diagnosis prediction in healthcare. In this paper, we present a novel dynamic framework for thinking about the deployment of ML models in a performative, human-ML collaborative system. In our framework, the introduction of ML recommendations changes the data generating process of human decisions, which are only a proxy to the ground truth and which are then used to train future versions of the model. We show that this dynamic process in principle can converge to different stable points, i.e. where the ML model and the Human+ML system have the same performance. Some of these stable points are suboptimal with respect to the actual ground truth. We conduct an empirical user study with 1,408 participants to showcase this process. In the study, humans solve instances of the knapsack problem with the help of machine learning predictions. This is an ideal setting because we can see how ML models learn to imitate human decisions and how this learning process converges to a stable point. We find that for many levels of ML performance, humans can improve the ML predictions to dynamically reach an equilibrium performance that is around 92% of the maximum knapsack value. We also find that the equilibrium performance could be even higher if humans rationally followed the ML recommendations. Finally, we test whether monetary incentives can increase the quality of human decisions, but we fail to find any positive effect. Our results have practical implications for the deployment of ML models in contexts where human decisions may deviate from the indisputable ground truth.
- [16] arXiv:2405.13879 (cross-list from cs.GT) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: FACT or Fiction: Can Truthful Mechanisms Eliminate Federated Free Riding?Comments: 18 pages, 5 figuresSubjects: Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Distributed, Parallel, and Cluster Computing (cs.DC); Machine Learning (cs.LG); Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
Standard federated learning (FL) approaches are vulnerable to the free-rider dilemma: participating agents can contribute little to nothing yet receive a well-trained aggregated model. While prior mechanisms attempt to solve the free-rider dilemma, none have addressed the issue of truthfulness. In practice, adversarial agents can provide false information to the server in order to cheat its way out of contributing to federated training. In an effort to make free-riding-averse federated mechanisms truthful, and consequently less prone to breaking down in practice, we propose FACT. FACT is the first federated mechanism that: (1) eliminates federated free riding by using a penalty system, (2) ensures agents provide truthful information by creating a competitive environment, and (3) encourages agent participation by offering better performance than training alone. Empirically, FACT avoids free-riding when agents are untruthful, and reduces agent loss by over 4x.
- [17] arXiv:2405.13926 (cross-list from stat.ME) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Some models are useful, but for how long?: A decision theoretic approach to choosing when to refit large-scale prediction modelsSubjects: Methodology (stat.ME); Econometrics (econ.EM)
Large-scale prediction models (typically using tools from artificial intelligence, AI, or machine learning, ML) are increasingly ubiquitous across a variety of industries and scientific domains. Such methods are often paired with detailed data from sources such as electronic health records, wearable sensors, and omics data (high-throughput technology used to understand biology). Despite their utility, implementing AI and ML tools at the scale necessary to work with this data introduces two major challenges. First, it can cost tens of thousands of dollars to train a modern AI/ML model at scale. Second, once the model is trained, its predictions may become less relevant as patient and provider behavior change, and predictions made for one geographical area may be less accurate for another. These two challenges raise a fundamental question: how often should you refit the AI/ML model to optimally trade-off between cost and relevance? Our work provides a framework for making decisions about when to {\it refit} AI/ML models when the goal is to maintain valid statistical inference (e.g. estimating a treatment effect in a clinical trial). Drawing on portfolio optimization theory, we treat the decision of {\it recalibrating} versus {\it refitting} the model as a choice between ''investing'' in one of two ''assets.'' One asset, recalibrating the model based on another model, is quick and relatively inexpensive but bears uncertainty from sampling and the possibility that the other model is not relevant to current circumstances. The other asset, {\it refitting} the model, is costly but removes the irrelevance concern (though not the risk of sampling error). We explore the balancing act between these two potential investments in this paper.
- [18] arXiv:2405.14279 (cross-list from cs.GT) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Optimized Cost Per Click in Online Advertising: A Theoretical AnalysisComments: Accepted by SIGKDD2024 Research TrackSubjects: Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
In recent years, Optimized Cost Per Click (OCPC) and Optimized Cost Per Mille (OCPM) have emerged as the most widely adopted pricing models in the online advertising industry. However, the existing literature has yet to identify the specific conditions under which these models outperform traditional pricing models like Cost Per Click (CPC) and Cost Per Action (CPA). To fill the gap, this paper builds an economic model that compares OCPC with CPC and CPA theoretically, which incorporates out-site scenarios and outside options as two key factors. Our analysis reveals that OCPC can effectively replace CPA by tackling the problem of advertisers strategically manipulating conversion reporting in out-site scenarios where conversions occur outside the advertising platform. Furthermore, OCPC exhibits the potential to surpass CPC in platform payoffs by providing higher advertiser payoffs and consequently attracting more advertisers. However, if advertisers have less competitive outside options and consistently stay in the focal platform, the platform may achieve higher payoffs using CPC. Our findings deliver valuable insights for online advertising platforms in selecting optimal pricing models, and provide recommendations for further enhancing their payoffs. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to analyze OCPC from an economic perspective. Moreover, our analysis can be applied to the OCPM model as well.
- [19] arXiv:2405.14575 (cross-list from cs.GT) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Share-Based Fairness for Arbitrary EntitlementsSubjects: Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
We consider the problem of fair allocation of indivisible items to agents that have arbitrary entitlements to the items. Every agent $i$ has a valuation function $v_i$ and an entitlement $b_i$, where entitlements sum up to~1. Which allocation should one choose in situations in which agents fail to agree on one acceptable fairness notion? We study this problem in the case in which each agent focuses on the value she gets, and fairness notions are restricted to be {\em share based}. A {\em share} $s$ is an function that maps every $(v_i,b_i)$ to a value $s(v_i,b_i)$, representing the minimal value $i$ should get, and $s$ is {\em feasible} if it is always possible to give every agent $i$ value of at least $s(v_i,b_i)$.
Our main result is that for additive valuations over goods there is an allocation that gives every agent at least half her share value, regardless of which feasible share-based fairness notion the agent wishes to use. Moreover, the ratio of half is best possible. More generally, we provide tight characterizations of what can be achieved, both ex-post (as single allocations) and ex-ante (as expected values of distributions of allocations), both for goods and for chores. We also show that for chores one can achieve the ex-ante and ex-post guarantees simultaneously (a ``best of both world" result), whereas for goods one cannot.
Cross submissions for Friday, 24 May 2024 (showing 6 of 6 entries )
- [20] arXiv:2007.13804 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: The Spectral Approach to Linear Rational Expectations ModelsComments: JEL Classification: C10, C32, C62, E32Subjects: Econometrics (econ.EM); Statistics Theory (math.ST)
This paper considers linear rational expectations models in the frequency domain. The paper characterizes existence and uniqueness of solutions to particular as well as generic systems. The set of all solutions to a given system is shown to be a finite dimensional affine space in the frequency domain. It is demonstrated that solutions can be discontinuous with respect to the parameters of the models in the context of non-uniqueness, invalidating mainstream frequentist and Bayesian methods. The ill-posedness of the problem motivates regularized solutions with theoretically guaranteed uniqueness, continuity, and even differentiability properties.
- [21] arXiv:2012.02708 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: A Multivariate Realized GARCH ModelSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM)
We propose a novel class of multivariate GARCH models that utilize realized measures of volatilities and correlations. The central component is an unconstrained vector parametrization of the conditional correlation matrix that facilitates factor models for correlations. This offers an elegant solution to the primary challenge that plagues multivariate GARCH models in high-dimensional settings. As an illustration, we consider block correlation structures that naturally simplify to linear factor models for the conditional correlations. We apply the model to returns of nine assets and inspect in-sample and out-of-sample model performance in comparison with several popular benchmarks.
- [22] arXiv:2108.01026 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: US Spillovers of US Monetary Policy: Information effects & Financial FlowsSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
This paper quantifies the international spillovers of US interest rates by explicitly controlling for the "Fed Information Effect". I use multiple identification strategies that identify two components of monetary policy surprises around FOMC meetings: a pure US monetary policy shock component and a "Fed Information Effect" component. On the one hand, a US tightening caused by a pure US monetary policy component leads to an economic recession, an exchange rate depreciation and tighter financial conditions. On the other hand, a tightening of US monetary policy caused by the "Fed Information Effect" leads to an economic expansion, an exchange rate appreciation and looser financial conditions. Ignoring the "Fed Information Effect" biases the impact of US interest rates and may explain recent atypical findings which suggest an expansionary impact of US monetary policy shocks on the rest of the world.
- [23] arXiv:2204.07474 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: The comparative statics of persuasionSubjects: Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
In the canonical persuasion model, comparative statics has been an open question. We answer it, delineating which shifts of the sender's interim payoff lead her optimally to choose a more informative signal. Our first theorem identifies a coarse notion of 'increased convexity' that we show characterises those shifts of the sender's interim payoff that lead her optimally to choose no less informative signals. To strengthen this conclusion to 'more informative' requires further assumptions: our second theorem identifies the necessary and sufficient condition on the sender's interim payoff, which strictly generalises the 'S' shape commonly imposed in the literature. We identify conditions under which increased alignment of interests between sender and receiver lead to comparative statics, and study a number of applications.
- [24] arXiv:2208.14972 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Making the Elite: Top Jobs, Disparities, and SolutionsComments: Improved exposition for additional claritySubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
How do socioeconomically unequal screening practices impact access to elite firms and what policies might reduce inequality? Using personnel data from elite U.S. and European multinational corporations recruiting from an elite Indian college, I show that caste disparities in hiring do not arise in many job search stages, including: applications, application reading, written aptitude tests, large group debates that assess socio-emotional skills, and job choices. Rather, disparities arise in the final round, comprising non-technical personal interviews that screen on family background, neighborhood, and "cultural fit." These characteristics are plausibly weakly correlated with productivity (at the interview round) but strongly correlated with caste. Employer willingness to pay for an advantaged caste is as large as that for a full standard deviation increase in college GPA. A hiring subsidy that eliminates the caste penalty would be more cost-effective in diversifying elite hiring than equalizing the caste distribution of pre-college test scores or enforcing hiring quotas.
- [25] arXiv:2308.05564 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Large Skew-t Copula Models and Asymmetric Dependence in Intraday Equity ReturnsSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM); Machine Learning (cs.LG); Statistical Finance (q-fin.ST); Computation (stat.CO)
Skew-t copula models are attractive for the modeling of financial data because they allow for asymmetric and extreme tail dependence. We show that the copula implicit in the skew-t distribution of Azzalini and Capitanio (2003) allows for a higher level of pairwise asymmetric dependence than two popular alternative skew-t copulas. Estimation of this copula in high dimensions is challenging, and we propose a fast and accurate Bayesian variational inference (VI) approach to do so. The method uses a generative representation of the skew-t distribution to define an augmented posterior that can be approximated accurately. A stochastic gradient ascent algorithm is used to solve the variational optimization. The methodology is used to estimate skew-t factor copula models with up to 15 factors for intraday returns from 2017 to 2021 on 93 U.S. equities. The copula captures substantial heterogeneity in asymmetric dependence over equity pairs, in addition to the variability in pairwise correlations. In a moving window study we show that the asymmetric dependencies also vary over time, and that intraday predictive densities from the skew-t copula are more accurate than those from benchmark copula models. Portfolio selection strategies based on the estimated pairwise asymmetric dependencies improve performance relative to the index.
- [26] arXiv:2310.15512 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Inference for Rank-Rank RegressionsSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM); Statistics Theory (math.ST)
Slope coefficients in rank-rank regressions are popular measures of intergenerational mobility. In this paper, we first point out two important properties of the OLS estimator in such regressions: commonly used variance estimators do not consistently estimate the asymptotic variance of the OLS estimator and, when the underlying distribution is not continuous, the OLS estimator may be highly sensitive to the way in which ties are handled. Motivated by these findings we derive the asymptotic theory for the OLS estimator in a general rank-rank regression specification without making assumptions about the continuity of the underlying distribution. We then extend the asymptotic theory to other regressions involving ranks that have been used in empirical work. Finally, we apply our new inference methods to three empirical studies. We find that the confidence intervals based on estimators of the correct variance may sometimes be substantially shorter and sometimes substantially longer than those based on commonly used variance estimators. The differences in confidence intervals concern economically meaningful values of mobility and thus may lead to different conclusions when comparing mobility across different regions or countries.
- [27] arXiv:2310.17571 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Inside the black box: Neural network-based real-time prediction of US recessionsSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM); Machine Learning (stat.ML)
Long short-term memory (LSTM) and gated recurrent unit (GRU) are used to model US recessions from 1967 to 2021. Their predictive performances are compared to those of the traditional linear models. The out-of-sample performance suggests the application of LSTM and GRU in recession forecasting, especially for longer-term forecasts. The Shapley additive explanations (SHAP) method is applied to both groups of models. The SHAP-based different weight assignments imply the capability of these types of neural networks to capture the business cycle asymmetries and nonlinearities. The SHAP method delivers key recession indicators, such as the S&P 500 index for short-term forecasting up to 3 months and the term spread for longer-term forecasting up to 12 months. These findings are robust against other interpretation methods, such as the local interpretable model-agnostic explanations (LIME) and the marginal effects.
- [28] arXiv:2402.04429 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Meritocracy and Its Discontents: Long-run Effects of Repeated School Admission ReformsComments: Keywords: Elite Education, Market Design, Strategic Behavior, Regional Mobility, Universal Access, Persistent EffectsSubjects: General Economics (econ.GN)
What happens if selective colleges change their admission policies? We study this question by analyzing the world's first implementation of nationally centralized meritocratic admissions in the early twentieth century. We find a persistent meritocracy-equity tradeoff. Compared to the decentralized system, the centralized system admitted more high-achievers and produced more occupational elites (such as top income earners) decades later in the labor market. This gain came at a distributional cost, however. Meritocratic centralization also increased the number of urban-born elites relative to rural-born ones, undermining equal access to higher education and career advancement.
- [29] arXiv:2402.15418 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Reputational Algorithm AversionSubjects: Theoretical Economics (econ.TH); Artificial Intelligence (cs.AI); Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Human-Computer Interaction (cs.HC)
People are often reluctant to incorporate information produced by algorithms into their decisions, a phenomenon called ``algorithm aversion''. This paper shows how algorithm aversion arises when the choice to follow an algorithm conveys information about a human's ability. I develop a model in which workers make forecasts of an uncertain outcome based on their own private information and an algorithm's signal. Low-skill workers receive worse information than the algorithm and hence should always follow the algorithm's signal, while high-skill workers receive better information than the algorithm and should sometimes override it. However, due to reputational concerns, low-skill workers inefficiently override the algorithm to increase the likelihood they are perceived as high-skill. The model provides a fully rational microfoundation for algorithm aversion that aligns with the broad concern that AI systems will displace many types of workers.
- [30] arXiv:2403.04029 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Two-Person Adversarial Games are Zero-Sum: An Elaboration of a Folk TheoremSubjects: Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
The observation that every two-person adversarial game is an affine transformation of a zero-sum game is traceable to Luce-Raiffa (1957) and made explicit in Aumann (1987). Recent work of (ADP) Adler-Daskalakis-Papadimitriou (2009), and of Raimondo (2023) in increasing generality, proves what has so far remained a conjecture. We present two proofs of an even more general formulation: the first draws on multilinear utility theory developed by Fishburn-Roberts (1978); the second is a consequence of the ADP proof itself for a special case of a two-player game with a set of three actions.
- [31] arXiv:2403.16632 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Risk Propagation in Endogenous Supply ChainsSubjects: Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
This paper investigates the endogenous formation of supply chains and its consequences for disruption propagation. In production networks where upstream risk is highly correlated and supplier relationships are not observable, the marginal risk reduction of adding an additional supplier is low, because this additional supplier's risk is likely to be correlated to that of the firm's existing suppliers. This channel reduces firm incentives to diversify, which gives rise to inefficiently fragile production networks.
By solving the social planner problem, I show that, if the risk reduction experienced downstream resulting from upstream diversification were to be internalised by upstream firms, endogenous production networks would be resilient to most levels of risk. Furthermore, I show that imperfect information yields inefficient but more robust supply chains. Despite its stylised form, the model identifies the trade-off firms face when diversifying risk and isolates the mechanism that aggregates these decisions into a production network. Furthermore, it maps the conditions of the trade-off, such as expected profits of the firm or the sourcing costs, to the properties of the production network. - [32] arXiv:2404.09467 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: The Role of Carbon Pricing in Food Inflation: Evidence from Canadian ProvincesSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM)
In the search for political-economic tools for greenhouse gas mitigation, carbon pricing, which includes carbon tax and cap-and-trade, is implemented by many governments. However, the inflating food prices in carbon-pricing countries, such as Canada, have led many to believe such policies harm food affordability. This study aims to identify changes in food prices induced by carbon pricing using the case of Canadian provinces. Using the staggered difference-in-difference (DiD) approach, we find an overall deflationary effect of carbon pricing on food prices (measured by monthly provincial food CPI). The average reductions in food CPI compared to before carbon pricing are $2\%$ and $4\%$ within and beyond two years of implementation. We further find that the deflationary effects are partially driven by lower consumption with no significant change via farm input costs. Evidence in this paper suggests no inflationary effect of carbon pricing in Canadian provinces, thus giving no support to the growing voices against carbon pricing policies.
- [33] arXiv:2405.08222 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Random Utility Models with Skewed Random Components: the Smallest versus Largest Extreme Value DistributionSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM)
At the core of most random utility models (RUMs) is an individual agent with a random utility component following a largest extreme value Type I (LEVI) distribution. What if, instead, the random component follows its mirror image -- the smallest extreme value Type I (SEVI) distribution? Differences between these specifications, closely tied to the random component's skewness, can be quite profound. For the same preference parameters, the two RUMs, equivalent with only two choice alternatives, diverge progressively as the number of alternatives increases, resulting in substantially different estimates and predictions for key measures, such as elasticities and market shares.
The LEVI model imposes the well-known independence-of-irrelevant-alternatives property, while SEVI does not. Instead, the SEVI choice probability for a particular option involves enumerating all subsets that contain this option. The SEVI model, though more complex to estimate, is shown to have computationally tractable closed-form choice probabilities. Much of the paper delves into explicating the properties of the SEVI model and exploring implications of the random component's skewness.
Conceptually, the difference between the LEVI and SEVI models centers on whether information, known only to the agent, is more likely to increase or decrease the systematic utility parameterized using observed attributes. LEVI does the former; SEVI the latter. An immediate implication is that if choice is characterized by SEVI random components, then the observed choice is more likely to correspond to the systematic-utility-maximizing choice than if characterized by LEVI. Examining standard empirical examples from different applied areas, we find that the SEVI model outperforms the LEVI model, suggesting the relevance of its inclusion in applied researchers' toolkits. - [34] arXiv:2405.12083 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Instrumented Difference-in-Differences with heterogeneous treatment effectsComments: 62 pagesSubjects: Econometrics (econ.EM)
Many studies exploit variation in the timing of policy adoption across units as an instrument for treatment, and use instrumental variable techniques. This paper formalizes the underlying identification strategy as an instrumented difference-in-differences (DID-IV). In a simple setting with two periods and two groups, our DID-IV design mainly consists of a monotonicity assumption, and parallel trends assumptions in the treatment and the outcome. In this design, a Wald-DID estimand, which scales the DID estimand of the outcome by the DID estimand of the treatment, captures the local average treatment effect on the treated (LATET). In contrast to Fuzzy DID design considered in \cite{De_Chaisemartin2018-xe}, our DID-IV design does not {\it ex-ante} require strong restrictions on the treatment adoption behavior across units, and our target parameter, the LATET, is policy-relevant if the instrument is based on the policy change of interest to the researcher. We extend the canonical DID-IV design to multiple period settings with the staggered adoption of the instrument across units, which we call staggered DID-IV designs. We propose an estimation method in staggered DID-IV designs that is robust to treatment effect heterogeneity. We illustrate our findings in the setting of \cite{Oreopoulos2006-bn}, estimating returns to schooling in the United Kingdom. In this application, the two-way fixed effects instrumental variable regression, which is the conventional approach to implement staggered DID-IV designs, yields a negative estimate, whereas our estimation method indicates the substantial gain from schooling.
- [35] arXiv:2210.07793 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Discrete & Bayesian Transaction Fee MechanismsComments: 28 pagesSubjects: Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
Cryptocurrencies employ auction-esque transaction fee mechanisms (TFMs) to allocate transactions to blocks, and to determine how much fees miners can collect from transactions. Several impossibility results show that TFMs that satisfy a standard set of "good" properties obtain low revenue, and in certain cases, no revenue at all. In this work, we circumvent previous impossibilities by showing that when desired TFM properties are reasonably relaxed, simple mechanisms can obtain strictly positive revenue. By discretizing fees, we design a TFM that satisfies the extended TFM desiderata: it is dominant strategy incentive-compatible (DSIC), myopic miner incentive-compatible (MMIC), side-contract-proof (SCP) and obtains asymptotically optimal revenue (i.e., linear in the number of allocated bids), and optimal revenue when considering separable TFMs. If instead of discretizing fees we relax the DSIC and SCP properties, we show that Bitcoin's TFM, after applying the revelation principle, is Bayesian incentive-compatible (BIC), MMIC, off-chain-agreement (OCA) proof, and approximately revenue-optimal. We reach our results by characterizing the class of multi-item OCA-proof mechanisms, which may be of independent interest.
- [36] arXiv:2310.13681 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Towards Realistic Mechanisms That Incentivize Federated Participation and ContributionComments: 24 pages, 11 figuresSubjects: Computer Science and Game Theory (cs.GT); Computers and Society (cs.CY); Distributed, Parallel, and Cluster Computing (cs.DC); Machine Learning (cs.LG); Theoretical Economics (econ.TH)
Edge device participation in federating learning (FL) is typically studied through the lens of device-server communication (e.g., device dropout) and assumes an undying desire from edge devices to participate in FL. As a result, current FL frameworks are flawed when implemented in realistic settings, with many encountering the free-rider dilemma. In a step to push FL towards realistic settings, we propose RealFM: the first federated mechanism that (1) realistically models device utility, (2) incentivizes data contribution and device participation, (3) provably removes the free-rider dilemma, and (4) relaxes assumptions on data homogeneity and data sharing. Compared to previous FL mechanisms, RealFM allows for a non-linear relationship between model accuracy and utility, which improves the utility gained by the server and participating devices. On real-world data, RealFM improves device and server utility, as well as data contribution, by over 3 and 4 magnitudes respectively compared to baselines.
- [37] arXiv:2311.14676 (replaced) [pdf, ps, html, other]
-
Title: Decoding Social Sentiment in DAO: A Comparative Analysis of Blockchain Governance CommunitiesSubjects: Computers and Society (cs.CY); Cryptography and Security (cs.CR); Human-Computer Interaction (cs.HC); General Economics (econ.GN); Applications (stat.AP)
Blockchain technology is leading a revolutionary transformation across diverse industries, with effective governance being critical for the success and sustainability of blockchain projects. Community forums, pivotal in engaging decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs), significantly impact blockchain governance decisions. Concurrently, Natural Language Processing (NLP), particularly sentiment analysis, provides powerful insights from textual data. While prior research has explored the potential of NLP tools in social media sentiment analysis, there is a gap in understanding the sentiment landscape of blockchain governance communities. The evolving discourse and sentiment dynamics on the forums of top DAOs remain largely unknown. This paper delves deep into the evolving discourse and sentiment dynamics on the public forums of leading DeFi projects: Aave, Uniswap, Curve DAO, Yearn.finance, Merit Circle, and Balancer, focusing primarily on discussions related to governance issues. Our study shows that participants in decentralized communities generally express positive sentiments during Discord discussions. Furthermore, there is a potential interaction between discussion intensity and sentiment dynamics; higher discussion volume may contribute to a more stable sentiment from code analysis. The insights gained from this study are valuable for decision-makers in blockchain governance, underscoring the pivotal role of sentiment analysis in interpreting community emotions and its evolving impact on the landscape of blockchain governance. This research significantly contributes to the interdisciplinary exploration of the intersection of blockchain and society, specifically emphasizing the decentralized blockchain governance ecosystem. We provide our data and code for replicability as open access on GitHub.